Every solar quote arrives with a payback period on the front page. Seven years. Nine years. Six, if you sign this month. The number is the product of a dozen assumptions, most of which are not shown, several of which are optimistic, and one of which — the export rate — moves the answer more than everything else combined.
The calculation is not hard. You can rebuild it in half an hour from your own electricity bills, and doing so is the difference between evaluating an investment and accepting a marketing figure.
What changed in 2026
- Export rates fell in many markets. The generous feed-in arrangements that made early solar attractive have largely been replaced by lower rates, which shifted the economics decisively toward self-consumption.
- Panel prices kept dropping while installation costs did not. Hardware is a shrinking share of a quote; labour, scaffolding, and electrical work are increasingly the bulk of it.
- Batteries got cheaper and still rarely pay back on price arbitrage alone. They earn their place on resilience and self-consumption, which is a different argument from the one usually made.
- Time-of-use tariffs spread. Where they exist, when you use power matters as much as how much, which changes the calculation substantially.
The number that actually matters
Solar saves you money two ways, and they are worth very different amounts.
Self-consumption. Power your panels generate that you use immediately. This is worth the full retail rate you would otherwise have paid — the expensive number on your bill.
Export. Power you generate and do not use, sold back to the grid. This is worth whatever your export rate is, which in most markets is now a fraction of the retail rate.
The gap between those two is the whole game. If retail is three or four times the export rate, a unit used at home is worth three or four times a unit exported. Two households with identical systems and identical generation can have payback periods years apart purely because one uses more of its own output.
Which means the productive question is not "how many panels" but "how much of this will I use myself?" A household where everyone is out all day exports most of its midday peak. One with someone home, an EV charging, or a heat pump running consumes far more of it.
Rebuilding the calculation
| Input |
Where to get it |
Watch for |
| Annual consumption |
Your bills, in kWh not currency |
Use a full year |
| Retail rate |
Your bill, including standing charges |
Rates change |
| Export rate |
Your supplier's current tariff |
Quotes often assume better |
| Estimated generation |
Quote, or a public solar calculator |
Check roof orientation and shading |
| Self-consumption share |
Your own usage pattern |
The most under-examined input |
| System cost |
Quote, after any incentives |
Include all work, not just panels |
| Degradation |
Typically a small annual decline |
Should be stated |
Annual saving is roughly: (generation × self-consumption share × retail rate) + (generation × export share × export rate). Divide system cost by that, and you have a payback period in years before adjusting for degradation and future rate changes.
Then test the sensitive inputs. Re-run it with the export rate halved. Re-run it with self-consumption ten points lower than assumed. If the answer swings by years, that is where to focus your scrutiny — and it usually does.
The half-hour of your own usage data beats any modelled estimate. Half-hourly consumption from a smart meter tells you exactly how much daytime load you have, which is the number the whole calculation turns on.
Self-consumption is the lever
Given that the retail-versus-export gap dominates, the highest-return action after installation is not adding capacity. It is moving load into daylight.
Dishwasher and laundry on a daytime timer. EV charging during the day where your pattern allows — this one is large, since an EV is often the biggest single load in a house, and EV charging at home covers scheduling it. Water heating timed to midday. A heat pump running during generation hours rather than overnight.
None of this costs anything, and collectively it can shift self-consumption by a meaningful margin — which moves payback more than another few panels would.
It also reframes batteries correctly. A battery stores midday excess for evening use, converting exported units into self-consumed ones. Whether that pays depends on the same rate gap, the battery's cost, and its cycle life — and on current pricing it frequently lengthens payback rather than shortening it. That does not make batteries pointless; backup power during outages is a real benefit that people value independently. It just is not usually a financial argument.
Common mistakes
- Accepting the quoted payback without the assumptions. Ask for the export rate, degradation, and self-consumption figures used.
- Ignoring self-consumption entirely. The largest determinant, and the one most quotes gloss over.
- Assuming today's export rate is permanent. It has moved before and can move again.
- Sizing to annual consumption. Matching yearly totals still exports most of summer and imports most of winter.
- Not accounting for roof orientation and shading. A partly-shaded roof underperforms badly, and generation estimates should reflect it.
- Buying a battery on financial grounds alone. Buy it for resilience; treat any savings as a bonus.
- Skipping the envelope work first. Reducing consumption is cheaper per unit than generating — see home energy audit.
FAQ
Is solar worth it if I might move?
Depends heavily on whether it adds resale value in your market, which varies. A system that has not paid back is not automatically a loss on sale, and it is rarely recovered in full either. Shorter expected tenure argues for scrutinising payback harder.
What about the roof?
If it needs replacing within roughly a decade, do it before installing. Removing and refitting panels to replace a roof underneath them is a substantial avoidable cost.
Do panels really last 25 years?
Panels typically degrade slowly and keep producing well beyond payback. Inverters usually do not last that long and should be budgeted as a replacement during the system's life — a cost some quotes omit entirely.
Should I wait for prices to fall further?
Hardware keeps getting cheaper; installation costs are stickier, and incentives can move either way. Waiting indefinitely for a better deal also means paying full retail for electricity in the meantime. Run the numbers on today's terms rather than a forecast.
Where to go next
For reducing consumption before generating any, read home energy audit. For the load that most changes your self-consumption maths, EV charging at home, and for the water heating side, the heat pump water heater guide.
This is general information, not financial advice. Rates, incentives, and export arrangements vary substantially by region and change frequently; use your own current figures.